Transparency in Commercial Real Estate Investment
“Honesty.” “Integrity.” “Transparency.” All are overused, vague words, especially in commercial real estate investment. Throw in “client service” and “expertise,” and that covers nearly every attribute financial service companies tout to potential investors.
We value these words at Origin Investments. But our motto is to build them into our process, documents and systems rather than just tout them on our website or in materials. In other words, show — don’t tell.
Commercial Real Estate Investment at Origin
Transparency means providing our partners with the information we have in real time. We’ve spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on technology and people to make transparency a part of the way we do business. All of our asset values, business plans and updates are readily available to our partners through our proprietary investment management system at origininvests.wpengine.com.
It’s simple, effective and immediate. Each of our partners has an individual portal page, where they can log in, see the current state of their investment portfolio and read about the performance of any asset at Origin.
We don’t like surprises and know our investors don’t either. We send updates every quarter on all of our investments. If something else material occurs within this time frame, either positive or negative, we send that information as well. In short, our partners know what we know. That’s true transparency.
Our Definition Of Transparency
We believe transparency exists when investors are supplied with all the information they need in an easily available way.
Conforming to the minimum standards of law so you won’t get sued does not meet our definition of transparency. All investment managers are required by law to disclose conflicts of interest and fees in their prospectuses. These are often long, tedious documents, and the information is buried in the back. This makes it hard to see what their fees really are and understand how their distributions work. While this tactic conforms to disclosure laws, it doesn’t meet our definition of transparency.
These tactics cloud the true nature of the costs of investing in vehicles such as non-traded and private REITs.
Fees are only one issue. According to the Investment Program Association (IPA): The up-front fees associated with investing in a non-traded REIT may be in the range of 12 percent to 15 percent” and may involve other fees over the investment’s life.
Why would anyone knowingly get into an investment where they’ve lost 15% on day one?
“No brokerage should be allowed to sell these things,” former Securities and Exchange Commission economist Craig McCann told The Wall Street Journal.
Share price is also hard to assess. How does a share price that never floats truly represent the value of the underlying assets and provide transparency? It is false logic to think these vehicles are more stable because the share price doesn’t float.
The security of dividends is another clever marketing trick. Most non-traded and private REITs don’t have the funds to pay all their investors’ dividends, so their managers entice investors into reinvesting it at a “discount” to share price. If the share price is $10, but the value of the underlying assets is $3, then reinvesting at $9.50 is akin to paying a 300 percent premium. But it is impossible to know this if the share price doesn’t float.
At Origin Investments, we are committed to true transparency. We champion it on our website, in our investor updates and in communications with potential investors. We’ve built it into the way we do business every day.