Investing Education

Mark-to-Market 101: What a NAV Adjustment Is (and Isn’t) Telling You

Mark-to-Market 101 What a NAV Adjustment Is and Isnt Telling You

Quick Take: Many private real estate funds report NAV monthly or quarterly¹, and investors often assume that number means something changed within the fund itself. Often, it reflects a change in market conditions. Understanding the difference between a valuation adjustment and a performance signal can be a useful distinction for a private markets investor.

A net asset value (NAV) adjustment is not a report card. It is an estimate of what the portfolio would be worth in an orderly sale, based on current assumptions.² The distinction matters because investors are generally interested in two things: 1) whether the fund is performing, and 2) whether their capital is at risk, and a NAV adjustment answers neither on its own.

A NAV Adjustment Reflects a Change in Assumptions… Not Necessarily a Change in the Building

As an example, you can generally think of a NAV adjustment the way an appraiser thinks about a home. The kitchen has not changed, the roof has not changed, the building and its income have not changed. What has changed is the price a buyer would pay for it today, given prevailing interest rates, comparable sales, and investor appetite for risk. Private real estate valuations work in a similar way, applied across an entire portfolio.

Each property in a fund is periodically revalued using a capitalization rate, or “cap rate,” applied to the property’s net operating income (NOI) in order to estimate current market value.³ The formula for the cap rate is NOI divided by property value; a valuation is typically derived by dividing NOI by a market cap rate. When cap rates move, for example, because interest rates moved, capital availability shifted, or investor risk appetite changed, the resulting valuation moves too, even if the property’s operating performance has not changed at all.

Private Valuations Move Less Often, and Differently Than Public Markets

Public securities are marked to market continuously; a stock’s price reflects the market’s real-time consensus. Private real estate is not priced this way. Valuations are typically updated monthly or quarterly, which means private NAVs move in steps rather than in a continuous line.¹

This has a practical consequence: private real estate valuations have historically tended to lag the broader market rather than lead it.⁴ When interest rates rise sharply, publicly traded REITs are repriced by the market in real time, while private real estate valuations are updated periodically.⁴ In some periods, private fund NAVs have taken several quarters to catch up, as values incorporate new comparable transactions and updated cap rate assumptions.⁴ An investor comparing a private fund’s NAV to a public REIT’s daily price chart is comparing a periodic review to a real-time market price.

A Cap Rate Move Can Change NAV Without Touching a Single Lease

Here is where the confusion typically starts. Suppose a fund’s underlying properties are fully leased, rents are growing, and operating expenses are in line with budget, and the fund still reports a NAV decline that quarter. That is not a contradiction. If the market-wide cap rate (used to value similar properties) expanded by even half a percentage point, the appraised value of every property in the portfolio can decline, independent of how well those properties are actually operating. Because value is NOI divided by the cap rate, equal moves in the cap rate up or down do not produce equal percentage changes in value.

Hypothetical Illustration: How Cap Rate Changes Affect Property Value

Cap RateChange From 5.00%Property ValueValue Change
4.00%-100 bps$25,000,000+25.0% 
4.25%-75 bps$23,529,412+17.6% 
4.50%-50 bps$22,222,222+11.1% 
4.75%-25 bps$21,052,632+5.3% 
5.00%Starting point$20,000,000n/a 
5.25%+25 bps$19,047,619-4.8% 
5.50%+50 bps $18,181,818-9.1% 
5.75%+75 bps$17,391,304-13.0% 
6.00%+100 bps$16,666,667-16.7% 
Hypothetical illustration only. Value = NOI ÷ cap rate, assuming a hypothetical property with $1,000,000 NOI held constant and a hypothetical 5.00% starting cap rate. bps = basis points (25 bps = 0.25%). Percentages rounded to one decimal place. Not a fund or portfolio result. Does not reflect leverage, fees, or expenses. Actual results will vary.

This is the core translation an investor needs: a cap rate is the market’s price for a dollar of income, and that price is set externally, by capital markets — not internally, by an operator’s management decisions. A NAV adjustment driven by cap rate movement is generally a reflection of market conditions rather than a statement about the manager’s execution, though operating performance can contribute to the same NAV change.

A NAV Adjustment Is an Estimate, and It Can Reflect Real Problems as Well as Market Conditions 

Not every decline is market-driven. A NAV decline can also reflect deteriorating occupancy, weaker rent growth, rising expenses, higher borrowing costs, or credit stress at the property or fund level. Leverage can magnify these effects, so a modest decline in property value can produce a larger decline in the value of the equity. Because values are updated periodically and often lag transaction activity, NAVs can understate near-term volatility and may not reflect current market conditions at the time an investor makes a decision.⁵ Private real estate investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal.

What a NAV Adjustment Does Not Tell You 

A NAV adjustment does not, by itself, tell you about occupancy trends, rent growth, debt service coverage, or the quality of a fund’s underwriting. Those are operating metrics, and they move on their own timeline, driven by leasing activity and expense management. A fund can report a NAV decline in a quarter where occupancy and rent collections both improved because the valuation and the operations are answering different questions.

The Driver of a NAV Move Matters More Than the Move 

When a NAV adjustment appears on a statement, the useful question is “What drove it?” A decline attributable to broad cap rate expansion across the sector is a market-timing observation. A decline attributable to a specific asset’s deteriorating occupancy or rising expenses is an operating concern. Both can produce the same headline number, and only one of them points to a problem specific to the portfolio.

Sophisticated investors, and the advisors who serve them, read NAV adjustments alongside the underlying operating metrics: occupancy, rent growth, NOI trends, and debt service coverage. Together, those figures help separate a market-driven repricing from a portfolio-specific problem. If you have questions about how a valuation adjustment on your statement was derived, our investor relations team is glad to walk through it with you.


Sources:

  1. NCREIF, Data, Index and Products Guide 2026 (NFI-ODCE funds are subject to NCREIF Real Estate Information Standards, including quarterly valuations). https://ncreif.org/__static/jdj5jdewjenkzertexy1sktwwwu4mzvx/NCREIF-Data-and-Products-Guide-2026.pdf. Accessed October 20, 2026.
  2. Financial Accounting Standards Board, Accounting Standards Codification Topic 820, Fair Value Measurement, Subtopic 820-10-35. Accessed October 20, 2026.
  3. Appraisal Institute: https://www.appraisalinstitute.org/getmedia/656424ba-5673-483f-b454-4074803e2d0c/smathrev-e-new
  4. Pension Real Estate Association (PREA), Real Estate Valuations Overview. https://www.prea.org/publications/quarterly/real-estate-valuations-overview/. Accessed October 20, 2026. See also PREA Quarterly, appraisal lag article: https://docs.prea.org/pub/E4CC8214-E83A-C454-1282-9595ED59563F.
  5. Jeffrey D. Fisher, “US commercial real estate indices: the NCREIF Property Index,” BIS Papers. https://www.bis.org/publ/bppdf/bispap21zc.pdf. Accessed October 20, 2026.

This article is intended for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on, for investment, tax, legal or accounting advice. The information is provided as of the date indicated and is subject to change without notice. Origin Investments does not have any obligation to update the information contained herein. Certain information presented or relied upon in this article may come from third-party sources. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and may receive incorrect information from third-party providers. All tax strategies discussed herein involve complex rules and regulations. Investors should consult with qualified tax, legal, and financial advisors before implementing any strategy.